Tweak Your Biz » Finance » Facebook’s Failed IPO

Facebook’s Failed IPO



On the day of Facebook’s initial public offering (IPO), on May 18th, 2012, David Ebersman, the company’s Chief Financial Officer, valued the stock at $38 per share, making it one of the largest IPOs in history, raising $16 billion. It set a new record for the trading value of an IPO, and had been underwritten by three of the biggest banks in America – Morgan Stanley, JP Morgan, and Goldman Sachs.

Demand was thought so high that the company announced, two days before the IPO, that it would sell 25% more shares than had originally been planned. When the trading began, stocks shot up to $45. With all the hype building up to it, then, for what was, after all, the transformation of the world’s most popular social network from a private company into a public one, it might seem surprising that things went so drastically wrong.

But go wrong they did. After that initial surge the stock value dropped quickly from $38 to $32. Those banks that underwrote the IPO had to jump in and buy millions of shares between themselves to keep the value up, but that only slowed things down. During the ninety days after the IPO, Facebook’s market value dropped more than $50 billion. At its lowest point, in September, the stock was valued at just $17.55. So what went wrong, and why?

Facebook IPO

Great Expectations

Hype is a fickle thing. On the one hand, if something lives up to its hype, its popularity is likely to rise and rise. If, however, the eventual response is one of disappointment, the long-accumulated excitement can dissipate quickly. The last thing a company wants on the day it becomes public is bad publicity.

Even before the IPO, though, there was some skepticism of the high valuation, which some see as a response to LinkedIn’s IPO, in which a 110% rise in stock value due to mispricing resulted in $350 million effectively given away to investors. On the big day, the NASDAQ experienced technical problems, undermining confidence in the stock. When the IPO was then described by the media as disappointing, a self-fulfilling prophecy began to unfurl.

The next blow came when Wall Street regulators began an investigation to discover whether or not the banks underwriting the IPO had improperly shared information with select clients. Investors who had already lost money pounced on the issue and lawsuits were filed – hardly encouraging for future investors.

Deeper Issues

A more underlying reason for the failing IPO is Facebook’s position as an advertiser. The company had announced in its prospectus that they had 2.7 billion daily ‘likes’ and comments, but around 54% of those likers and commenters are younger than 44, with a large proportion in the lower half of that demographic. Young people don’t generally have much money, and so Facebook’s advertising platform is less attractive to clients than those of its rivals – Google, say, whose Google Wallet can ascertain what a customer wants, what that customer buys, and what that customer is willing to pay. Facebook’s revenue has always mostly come from advertising, though, and now that it’s become public, it needs to convince investors that it knows it is a business as well as a social network.

Light in the Tunnel

Despite this turmoil, recent signs point north. Bernstein Research Analyst, Carlos Kirjner, has recently determined that, using the ever driving growth delivered by mobile advertisements, Facebook can increase its number of ads without the degeneration of the overall Facebook experience for its users. And although he advises caution, pointing out that the long-term success of social advertising has yet to be proven, Facebook’s stock has recently been increasing with alacrity.

Although it has yet to regain its original IPO price, stock this week has surpassed the $30 dollar level, ending at $31.72 on Friday the 11th. What’s more, the quarterly performance review being announced later this month is expected to be a positive one, and positive momentum is the surest bet for investors.

After a catastrophic IPO which could have been avoided, or at least limited, the prospects for the future look brighter than ever. Of course investing is still a risk – but at this point it might just be a risk worth taking.

Did you like this article?  Write for the site. Sign up for our RSS.

Connect:                        

Images:  ”NEW YORK – MAY 18 Sign announcing Facebook IPO  / Shutterstock.com

 



The Author:

Simon is the owner of Simon's Online Marketing an online marketing agency focusing on clients in difficult niches and the Eureka Network. http://simonsblogpark.com/personal

Add Your Comment

  • http://www.bloggertone.com Niall Devitt

    I think the inital valuation meant that the Facebook share price had no where to go except down. That said, Facebook is now going to be much more focused on generating revenues and could mean good news for investors, provided they can continue to keep users happy.

  • http://about.me/Lindeskog lyceum1776

    I think it was a success that Facebook made it to the exchange. Now they have learned a lesson from this. The free market will take care of the situation. My question is: do you think that companies like Facebook and other tech companies will have the same influence like the old traditional manufacturing companies that are a big part of the Dow Jones Index, sometime in the future?

  • http://www.thesmarttrain.com/ Elaine Rogers

    Hi Simon, interesting post!
    I stay well clear of chancing my arm with shares. I read an article yesterday that convinced me it’s just not for me. However, as the rules and goalposts change with relation to traditional methods and angles, I think Facebook and peers, can teach us a new form of going public.
    Nothing is certain in this game, and just because they survived since, doesn’t mean investing in FB is now a sure bet. Just look at the history of Apple – enough to give anyone a heart attack over the past few weeks (especially the past few days)

    What built the stock markets before are not what may sustain them in future – the future is so uncertain for us mortals anyway, I certainly won’t be cashing in my post office savings :)